|
Book Review
Panzerwrecks 5 Panzerwrecks 5 | |
by: Matt McLean [ ]
IntroductionThe Panzerwrecks series of books are brought to us by William Auerbach and Lee Archer. They feature many rare and unpublished photos of wrecks or captured German WWII panzers. All of the volumes of Panzerwrecks follow the same soft cover, A4 landscape format, with black and white photos. Volume 5 of Panzerwrecks contains 153 rare and unpublished photos from various sources worldwide. This volume differs from previous ones in that it re-visits Panzerwrecks Vol. 1. The book is broken down into four main sections titled: “Panzerwrecks 1 Re-visited”, “Tiger II Joyride”, “Wrecks in Russian Newsreels”, and “Three Maus at Meppen”.
The BookThe first section that re-visits Panzerwrecks vol. 1 contains all new photos that relate to quite a few vehicles that were featured in the previous volume. 27 full pages are devoted to these new photos that include many inset shots, showing details that were not shown before. This re-visit to Panzerwrecks 1 allows Auerbach and Archer to clarify many of the missing details or specifications that weren’t available when volume 1 was published. Between sections one and two are 7 pages of wrecked Tiger 1’s, a Panther G, and a Pz.Kpfw. IV Ausf. H and G. These photos are of exceptional clarity and the captions provided offer a good description of the scenes.
Section two entitled “Tiger II Joyride,” is dedicated to a captured Tiger II belonging to s.H.Pz.Abt.506 by Co. B of the 129th Ordnance Battalion in December, 1944. This tank was covered briefly in Steve Zaloga's "Panzers in the Gunsights", but not in the detail that it is here in Panzerwrecks 5. The series of photos covers the preparations and starting of the Tiger II and consists of 6 full pages. Many unpublished photos are presented here and reveal key details that are of excellent value to historians and modelers alike.
Section three, entitled “Wrecks in Russian Newsreels,” brings us 9 pages of photos from the Eastern Front. The quality of these photos is not great, being dark and grainy at best, with little detail noticeable on many of the photos. They show an assortment of destroyed vehicles, but I question the usefulness of including these sub-par photos given the excellent quality of the others. Between sections three and four are 25 pages of various wrecks from the western European Theater. Everything from Tiger Is to various marks of Panzer tanks, even a captured T48 Gun Motor Carriage in use by the Germans is included. These are very interesting photos, and their inclusion is a definite plus.
The last section entitled “Three Maus at Meppen” has 5 pages of photos dedicated to unfinished Maus tanks. The photo quality is good, but they are a little dark. The book closes with some photos of Bulgarian soldiers inspecting abandoned German equipment presumably on the Eastern Front. They show excellent photos of the before and after effects of an explosion inside of a 7.5cm Pak 40 tank destroyer.
Conclusion As with all the Panzerwrecks books, this one is a must have. It brings many rare and unpublished photos together at a great price. The variety of the photos is a credit to the research efforts of Mr. Auerbach and Mr. Archer. A few grammatical corrections to the captions accompanying each picture is really all that is needed to make this book better, but they don’t effect the overall usefulness of this book. Highly Recommended. SUMMARY | Highs: Variety of photos included is great. The price for this book is very reasonable. Lows: Quality of some photos is poor. A few grammatical and description errors are included, but don't affect the overall usefulness. Verdict: Panzerwrecks 5 is highly recommended. |  |
93% |
| | | | Other | | | | ISBN 978-0955594014 | | | | $29.95 | | | | March 8th 2008 | | | | Germany |
|
About Matt McLean (MMcLean) Copyright ©2010 text by Matt McLean [ ]. Images also by copyright holder unless otherwise noted. Opinions expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of Armorama. All rights reserved.
Reader Reviews Do you own this item and want to review it? You can add your review of the item here. Please read the reader review instructions before posting. | |
| Comments (6) | |  |
wbill76 Matt McLean reviews the latest edition to the Panzerwrecks series by William Auerbach and Lee Archer, Panzerwrecks 5.
Link to Item
If you have comments or questions please post them here.
Thanks! dispatcher Matt, thanks for the review. Looks like I need to put another book on my want list. I had not seen extra armor on engine deck of a panther before, had heard about it.
Joe MMcLean Hi Joe,
The extra armour was a surprise to me too, but now its not too hard to build a kit with it, because of the Dragon release of there Italian Panther with roof armour. I recommend if your going to pick up Panzerwrecks 5 and are interested in the "uparmoured" panther, Panzerwrecks 1 would be a worthwhile investment too as it has some more photos of the same Panther.
Regards
Matt chlom got all five..............................can,t wait for number six.........got number six.... waiting on seven oh !!! mail man here let me go check with him.. chlom :-)--< Gt351 Have 1&2 in the series and they are great, cant wat to get them all, great stuff, cheers Bob. 8) |
|
 | What's Your Opinion?
   | | | 7 of 7 people found this review helpful. |
|

Photos CLICK IMAGE TO ZOOM |
|